Tuesday, November 15, 2011

Fallen Eagles

Larry Fitzgerald's second TD catch, which led to another Eagles loss.
To those of you reading that have already heard more than enough about and/or hate the Philadelphia Eagles: I am sorry. But I am a diehard fan, so I am going to write about them in order to get what I have to say about their struggles off my back.

Obviously, all of the talent is there for this team to win, but a number of factors hold them back.

I won't even address the linebacking issue much because it is blatantly obvious. Stewart Bradley was the only decent player at that position on this roster and he was let go, so now the team is left with a Clay Matthews look-alike and a couple of second stringers. Before the season I questioned why the team didn't at least take a look at free agent Lofa Tatupu; he had been a beast in the league for years and while he is aging, definitely presents a better option than what the team has right now.

But aside from the linebacker position, the personnel on this defense is incredible; regardless, the unit has still massively underachieved. Okay, first off, Juan Castillo needs to be let go. His zone scheme in the secondary is flat out awful. He has the arguably the best cornerbacks in the league on his roster (yes, I know they can't tackle, I'll get to that), but opposing QBs can still carve up the defense.

You could justify a Castillo firing for one reason alone: Larry Fitzgerald's performance in Sunday's game, which led to another Eagles fourth quarter collapse. Nnamdi Asomugha is up there with Darrelle Revis among the best cover corners in the NFL. So why, then, is he not assigned to stick to a team's number one receiver throughout the entire game? To put it into perspective: Asomugha covered Larry Fitzgerald on 20 of the 46 Cardinals' pass plays. In those 20 plays, Fitz was targeted twice and had no catches. When Asomugha was not on Fitz, but instead Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie, Kurt Coleman and a slew of other guys were, he had seven catches for 146 yards and two TDs.

All season I have wondered why Castillo hasn't had the corners play man; at least this game made his stupidity look obvious. All he needs to is have Nnamdi cover the one, Samuel the two, and Rodgers-Cromartie cover the three, and the opposing team will be forced to try check-downs and tight end slants the whole game. If pride becomes and issue among these three, Castillo simply needs to tell them to deal with it. And Castillo also needs to learn from the Jets on how to use a top corner, or even Oakland on how to use Asomugha, because he doesn't seem to get it.

Defensive front has been fine so far, no problems there. Except for maybe Cullen Jenkins, who is known for a lackluster work ethic...he had five sacks in the first five games, but has slacked off since and not gotten any. He is a talented player, and I expect him to turn it around.

The effort on defense overall has been terrible. No one is wrapping, and they are bouncing off ball-carriers like flies. Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie has been especially bad, lacking effort entirely. A few times I have seem him give up a pass, and rather than try to tackle the guy, just stop and hold up his hands like it was the beer vendor in the 45th row's fault. As a whole, though, the defense needs to learn the art of tackling, which you would think an NFL defense should have down by now.

And Michael Vick? Yeah, too much money. You could tell as last year wound down opposing teams were starting to figure him out, and this season has looked even worse. 100 million dollars was based off of eight good games, and recently he hasn't looked like any better a passer than he was in Atlanta, in fact probably worse. Thank goodness 60 million of the contract isn't guaranteed, as there was no way he would stay healthy for the entire life of the five year contract.

The o-line has been steadily improving. Rookies Jason Kelce and Danny Watkins are starting to come into their own, and Jason Peters is a beast. They've provided average pass blocking recently, but Peters especially has provided gaping holes for Shady McCoy.

Which brings me to another point. ANDY REID, RUN THE BALL! I can't believe that this is still a problem. I don't want to talk about it. McCoy is a god out there, and he only got fourteen carries last week...

Reid can gameplan after the bye, I will give him that. He's a good NFL coach. But his time has run out. He can no longer motivate this group of egotistic players. Someone needs to discipline this team more, get into their heads a little bit. And I don't think Reid is capable of it. Sure, he benched soon-to-be prima-donna DeSean Jackson for not showing up to a meeting (Meanwhile, DeSean's inconsistency is showing he isn't worth the big bucks as much as fellow receiver Jeremy Maclin). But that isn't enough. Reid's team has fallen apart in front of his eyes, and his exit after over a decade could be the cost.

The team's lack of effort should be placed more on the players than on Reid, but it is still the responsibility of the coach. The absence of fight was illustrated Sunday when Steve Smith, a guy with a ton of talent fighting for playing time, caught a pass two yards shy of a crucial first down with a defender approaching. Rather than fight to move the chains, he dove in front of the defender to avoid taking a hit, resulting in a critical punt. Now I hate to single out Smith, but plays like this have contributed to bringing this team down.

I will love this team for eternity, but they have a knack for pissing off the hometown fans.

2 comments:

  1. I agree with the fact that our secondary can't tackle and we should have signed linebackers and that Juan Costillo can't coach defense but the fault should be placed on the players for not trying to fight for a first down, dropping easy catches, and giving up stupid penalties that change the game. Michael Vick was givin a big contract because Andy Reid (a master of scouting qb's) saw something in Vick and gave him a shot to be our franchise quarterback. Also regarding ANdy Reid he brought succsess to the Eagles franchise by drafting Donovan McNabb in 1999 and since then his one big mistake was making Juan Costillo defensive coordinator. At the end of the season I predict the organization will fire Costillo. The full off-season coming up will give Andy Reid time to bring his team back together and have them play like they should. Also regarding Steward Bradley we didn't resign him because of the injuries e sustained in 09 and last season he didn't play well and never fully recovered from his torn ACL

    ReplyDelete
  2. Whether it is the players' faults or not, stupid penalties, not fighting for the first down etc. all travels back to the coach. I have been an Andy Reid fan for a long time but I think his time is up.

    And yes, I know why the organization signed Vick. But the final six games or so of last season foreshadowed Vick could struggle, and this year he has.

    As for Castillo, he's as good as gone.

    ReplyDelete